4.
Three graphs are shown below. Graph A shows$y = x^2 - 4$, Graph B shows$y = x^2 + 1$, and Graph C is incorrectly labeled as$y = x^2 - 4$but has a vertex at$(0, 4)$. Identify which graph is incorrect and explain why the vertex location contradicts the equation.
[GRAPH A: A parabola opening upward with vertex at$(0, -4)$, zeros at$(-2, 0)$and$(2, 0)$. Grid and axes are labeled.]
[GRAPH B: A parabola opening upward with vertex at$(0, 1)$, no x-intercepts visible. Grid and axes are labeled.]
[GRAPH C: A parabola opening upward with vertex at$(0, 4)$, labeled as$y = x^2 - 4$. Grid and axes are labeled.]
Answer: Graph C is incorrect. If the equation is$y = x^2 - 4$, then the vertex should be at$(0, -4)$, not$(0, 4)$. To verify: when$x = 0$,$y = (0)^2 - 4 = -4$. Graph C shows a vertex at$(0, 4)$, which would correspond to an equation like$y = x^2 + 4$, not$y = x^2 - 4$. The constant term in the equation determines the vertical shift of the parabola. A negative constant ($-4$) shifts the parabola down 4 units, while a positive constant ($+4$) shifts it up 4 units.
Common error: Students may confuse the sign of the constant term and its effect on the vertex. Reinforce that the y-coordinate of the vertex for$y = a(x - h)^2 + k$is$k$. In standard form$y = x^2 - 4$, we can rewrite as$y = (x - 0)^2 - 4$, so the vertex is at$(0, -4)$, not$(0, 4)$.